3 of the Best Places to Grab a Slice of Pizza in Cape Coral

A slice bigger than your head? A truffle mushroom Sicilian? A New York-style classic with thin crust, fresh-tasting sauce, and just the right crunch? We’ve been exploring pizza by the slice in Cape Coral, and these three local spots give you plenty to crave.
If you’re looking for pizza in Cape Coral, whether you go straight for pepperoni or like to try something different, here’s what we ordered and what stood out at each stop.
Long Island New York Pizza: Oversized Slices on Skyline
Bring your appetite to Long Island New York Pizza on Skyline Boulevard. During our original visit, I ordered the two-slice and drink special, and the slices were bigger than my head.



My pepperoni slice had those salty, crispy pepperoni edges I love, with a generous layer of melted cheese. The portions alone made an impression. That combination of pepperoni and cheese kept me going back for another bite.
Since our original visit, new owners have taken over, and we’ve loved seeing the great feedback they’re getting. We also ordered pizza, garlic knots, and mozzarella sticks for a pool party. Everything was phenomenal! Feeding a hungry pool-party crew gave us another reason to keep this Cape Coral pizza spot on our list.
📍 3812 Skyline Blvd, Unit E, Cape Coral
Mangia Bene Big Slice: Specialty Slices and Sicilian Pizza
Choosing just one slice at Mangia Bene Big Slice wasn’t happening. We stopped into this Del Prado Boulevard pizzeria to meet Anthony and his family. While there, we tried chicken bacon ranch, meat lover’s, truffle mushroom Sicilian-style, and classic cheese, all made with their homemade dough.
The chicken bacon ranch brings together savory chicken, bacon, and creamy ranch. It’s an easy choice if you love that combination and want to switch things up from your usual order. The meat lover’s gives you a heartier slice with plenty of meaty toppings.



The truffle mushroom Sicilian brings rich, earthy flavor on a thick Sicilian-style crust. It added a different texture and flavor to our lineup, making it a good one to include when you’re sampling a few slices.
And the classic cheese? It passed the flop test, holding its shape when we picked it up. Sometimes a simple slice is exactly what you’re craving, and this one earned its place alongside the specialty options.
Bring someone who likes to share, because you’ll want to try more than one.
📍 2301 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral
Sicily Trattoria: A New York-Style Favorite in the Heart of Cape Coral
Right in the heart of Cape Coral on Cape Coral Parkway, Sicily Trattoria serves the kind of New York-style pizza that makes you wonder why you waited so long to come back.
It had been about ten years since my first visit, and I remembered loving their pizza. This time, I ordered a classic cheese slice, while Edgard tried cheese and pepperoni, cooked well-done.



My slice was massive, with a thin crust, a little give through the middle, and a floury, crunchy edge. The sauce tasted light and fresh. The cheese melted beautifully, and everything was balanced so you could enjoy each part of the slice.
There wasn’t a puddle of grease on top, either. I could pick it up and enjoy it without reaching for a stack of napkins.
For anyone craving New York-style pizza in Cape Coral, this is a place where classic cheese deserves a spot in your order. If you prefer extra crunch, take a cue from Edgard and ask for yours well-done.
📍 1211 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral
Which Slice Would You Try First?
Oversized pepperoni on Skyline, truffle mushroom Sicilian on Del Prado, or a thin-crust classic on Cape Coral Parkway? These three pizzerias each gave us something to enjoy, and we’re always ready to discover another local favorite.
Tell us your go-to pizza spot and what we should order! Follow Cape Coral Reviewed on Instagram and Facebook for more local restaurants, honest experiences, and places to try around Cape Coral and Southwest Florida.
Stay Updated on Cape Coral
Get the latest local business reviews, events, and community news delivered straight to your inbox.
Comments (0)
Be the first to share your thoughts!