We’ve spent the past year eating our way through Cape Coral – sometimes for work, sometimes just because we love food. Between scratch-kitchen burgers, authentic Cuban plates, and waterfront dinners, these are the 10 spots our team keeps going back to.

If you’re new to Cape Coral (or just looking for your next meal), start here.

1. 10 Twenty Five – Scratch Kitchen Meets Craft Cocktails

“This is where we go when we want pub food done right—with a side of cocktails.”

Quick Take

🍔 Best Dishes: Short rib grilled cheese, brunch burgers, and chicken & waffles

💲 Price: Mid-range ($12–22)

🍹 Vibe: Modern, lively, creative

10 Twenty Five has become one of Cape Coral’s most talked-about pubs because they do more than just bar food. Everything’s scratch-made—from the sauces to the brunch plates. The short rib grilled cheese has a cult following (a Yelp reviewer called it “ridiculous in the best way”), and the brunch burger with a fried egg is a weekend favorite.

“We waited 25 minutes on a Saturday, but honestly, I’d wait twice as long for that burger and mimosa flight.”

Team Tip: Brunch here is underrated—mimosa flights and chicken & waffles hit the spot.

2. Ceno Grille – Cozy Italian & Greek Bistro

“Feels like dinner at a friend’s house—if your friend cooked everything from scratch.”

Quick Take

🍝 Best Dishes: Homemade lasagna, gyros, and Greek salads

💲 Price: Mid-range ($15–22)

🍷 Vibe: Warm, family-run, cozy

Ceno Grille is one of those restaurants locals want to keep secret. Run by a family with Greek roots, the food is hearty and comforting. The lasagna tastes like it’s been simmering all day, the gyros are tender and flavorful, and the Greek saladscome with warm pita that you’ll fight over.

“Best Greek food outside of Greece. And the bread? I’d come here just for the bread.”

Team Tip: Always ask about the daily specials—they often surprise you with something you won’t see on the menu again.

3. BackStreets Sports Bar – Pizza, Games & Live Music

“If we’re not watching the game at home, we’re probably at BackStreets.”

Quick Take

🍕 Best Dishes: NY-style pizza, wings, and daily specials

💲 Price: Affordable ($10–15 meals)

🎶 Vibe: Sports bar + karaoke + darts

BackStreets is as much about the energy as the food. Their NY-style pizza has a loyal fanbase, and the wings are solid. But what keeps people coming is the atmosphere—karaoke nights, trivia, darts, pool, and live bands that turn an ordinary night into a party.

“It’s not fancy, it’s fun. Pizza’s legit, drinks are cheap, and the crowd feels like family.”

Team Tip: Trivia nights here are more competitive than you’d think—grab a pizza, play, and don’t take it too seriously.

4. Cape Cabaret – Dinner & Dancing

“Dinner here almost always turns into dancing.”

Quick Take

🍗 Best Dishes: Roast chicken, meatloaf, and shrimp scampi

💲 Price: Mid-range ($15–30)

🎶 Vibe: Motown, ballroom, 50s–90s live bands

Cape Cabaret is an experience. The food is solid comfort fare (the meatloaf is a sleeper hit, and the shrimp scampi is a local favorite). But let’s be real—the reason you go is the live music and hardwood dance floor. From Motown to ballroom nights, this is dinner with entertainment built in.

“I dragged my husband here for dinner, and we ended up dancing like we were 25 again. Worth every penny.”

Team Tip: Book ahead for live band nights—they fill up fast.

5. Fathoms Restaurant & Bar – Upscale Marina Dining

“Dinner here feels like a vacation, even if you live down the street.”

Quick Take

🥂 Best Dishes: Blackened shrimp gnocchi, seafood paella, craft cocktails

💲 Price: Higher-end ($25–40)

⚓ Vibe: Stylish waterfront, marina setting

At Cape Harbour, Fathoms feels like the heart of the marina. It’s upscale but approachable, with a menu that blends global flavors. The blackened shrimp gnocchi is one of the most recommended dishes on Yelp, and the paella brings rave reviews for being loaded with seafood. Pair it with a cocktail, and you’ve got the perfect night out.

“We came by boat, stayed for the cocktails, and ended up closing the place down with dessert. Fathoms makes you linger.”

Team Tip: Grab a table outside at sunset—it’s the best dinner view in Cape Coral.

6. Gather – Contemporary Flavor at Tarpon Point

“When we want to impress visitors, we take them to Gather.”

Quick Take

🍤 Best Dishes: Duck wings, wagyu skirt steak, brunch specials

💲 Price: Mid- to high-range ($20–35)

🌴 Vibe: Modern, waterfront, social

Gather is sleek, stylish, and one of the best places to take out-of-town guests. The duck wings get nonstop love for being crispy and flavorful, and the wagyu skirt steak is a stunner. Brunch here deserves more attention too — Google reviews are full of photos of pancakes, Benedicts, and morning cocktails.

“If Naples feels too far, Gather is the perfect upscale spot in the Cape. We go monthly.”

Team Tip: Ask your server about seasonal cocktails—they put as much creativity into the drinks as the food.

7. House of Omlets – Breakfast Without Limits

“There are omelets, and then there are House of Omlets omelets.”

Quick Take

🍳 Best Dishes: Western omelet, pancake stacks, biscuits & gravy

💲 Price: Affordable ($10–15)

☕ Vibe: Cozy, busy mornings

House of Omlets is exactly what it sounds like—a temple to breakfast. Portions are massive, the menu is endless, and locals swear by the Western omelet and biscuits & gravy. The pancakes are “plate-sized and fluffy.”

“This is the only breakfast spot my kids actually beg to go to.”

Team Tip: Get there early on weekends—the line is no joke.

8. Lobster Lady – Fresh Seafood Market & Restaurant

“The lobster roll alone is worth the wait.”

Quick Take

🦞 Best Dishes: Lobster roll, crab legs, clam chowder

💲 Price: Mid- to high-range ($20–35)

🐟 Vibe: Seafood market meets casual dining

Lobster Lady is a Cape Coral institution. It’s loud, bustling, and always packed — but the lobster roll is worth it. The crab legs and clam chowder also get rave reviews. This is the spot to go when you want fresh seafood without the drive to the coast.

💬 Yelp reviewers warn: “Be ready to wait 30–40 minutes on weekends. But you’ll forget the wait when the lobster hits the table.”Team Tip: Skip peak dinner hours if you don’t want the wait — late lunch is easier.

9. Prime 239 Steakhouse – Elegant & Classic

“When we’re celebrating, this is where we book a table.”

Quick Take

🥩 Best Dishes: Filet mignon, seafood tower, crème brûlée

💲 Price: Higher-end ($30–60)

🍷 Vibe: Upscale, refined, date-night

Prime 239 is Cape Coral’s go-to steakhouse. Cuts are premium, sides are refined, and service is polished. The filet mignon is a must, but locals rave about the seafood tower for groups. Finish with the crème brûlée and you’ll feel like you’ve truly celebrated.

“Pricey, yes. But the service is flawless and the steak was the best I’ve had in Florida.”

Team Tip: If you’re going on a Friday or Saturday, reservations are a must.

10. Rincon Cubano – Authentic Cuban Comfort

“This is our go-to when we want food that feels like home cooking.”

Quick Take

🥪 Best Dishes: Cuban sandwich, ropa vieja, sweet plantains

💲 Price: Affordable ($10–15)

🎶 Vibe: Family-run, cozy, flavorful

Rincon Cubano is comfort food with soul. The Cuban sandwich is pressed to perfection, the ropa vieja is tender and savory, and the sweet plantains are the perfect side. Reviews on Yelp and Google consistently say the same thing: “authentic, generous, and friendly.”

“It’s the closest I’ve found to my abuela’s cooking.”

Team Tip: Don’t skip the Cuban coffee. It’s small but mighty.

Final Bite 🍽️

Cape Coral’s food scene is as diverse as its people. From high-end steak dinners to mom-and-pop Cuban gems, these are the restaurants we’ll keep recommending in 2025. Some nights call for cocktails by the marina, other nights call for takeout in front of the TV — Cape Coral has both covered.

💬 What’s your favorite Cape Coral restaurant? Drop it in the comments — or list your business on Cape Coral Reviewed so we can come check it out.